Navigating Sensitivity in Communication: Why to stop using “why.”

Cindy JobsADHD In The Workplace, Health and Well-Being, Organization, Productivity

Certain words hold significant weight in language and communication beyond their literal meanings. One such word is “why.” While often used innocuously to seek understanding or clarification, its impact can be unexpectedly triggering for many individuals. The reasons behind this sensitivity lie in its potential to evoke feelings of judgment, defensiveness, and vulnerability.

At its core, “why” can feel like an interrogation rather than an inquiry. When someone poses a question starting with “why,” it can come across as accusatory or critical, even if unintentional. This is particularly true when emotions are heightened, or opinions are strong. For example, asking, “Why did you do that?” can imply disapproval or disbelief, putting the recipient on the defensive.

Moreover, the word “why” has a way of digging into personal motivations and justifications, often delving into areas that individuals may not be comfortable discussing. It can feel invasive as if someone is demanding justification for actions or beliefs that are deeply personal. This invasion of privacy can trigger discomfort or resentment, especially if the individual feels pressured to justify themselves.

The word “why” can also carry a sense of invalidation. When asked, “Why do you feel that way?” or “Why is that important to you?” it can minimize their emotions or experiences, as if their feelings are unjustified without explanation. This invalidation can be particularly distressing for individuals struggling with self-expression or navigating sensitive topics.

In addition to its emotional implications, the word “why” can be triggering due to its association with power dynamics. In specific contexts, especially those involving authority figures or hierarchical relationships, asking “why” can challenge one’s autonomy or decision-making. This dynamic can be especially pronounced in professional settings or interactions with parents, teachers, or supervisors.

Moreover, the word “why” can evoke feelings of uncertainty or self-doubt. When asked, “Why do you think that?” or “Why did you say that?” it can prompt introspection and self-reflection, which may be uncomfortable for individuals who are unsure of themselves or fear judgment. This self-doubt can be exacerbated in social situations or environments where individuals feel insecure.

Recognizing the triggering power of “why” is crucial for fostering effective communication and maintaining healthy relationships. By being mindful of its impact, individuals can choose alternative language that promotes understanding and empathy without causing undue distress. For example, replacing “why” with “what” or “how” can shift the focus from judgment to exploration, encouraging open dialogue without triggering defensiveness or discomfort.

Active listening and empathy can be vital in mitigating the triggering effects of “why.” By validating others’ feelings and experiences, individuals can create a safe space for communication where they feel respected and understood. This can involve paraphrasing others’ words, asking open-ended questions, and demonstrating genuine curiosity without imposing judgment.

“Why” holds a unique power to trigger emotional responses and discomfort in communication. By understanding its impact and practicing alternative approaches, individuals can navigate sensitive conversations with greater empathy and respect. Fostering a culture of understanding and acceptance requires mindfulness and compassion in our choice of words and interactions.


Cindy Jobs, PCAC, PCC

Looking for more information?

Click here for ADHD-friendly Time Management Tools

Click here to schedule a complimentary breakthrough session.

For more helpful information, follow me on Facebook.